Judge throws out Pickett verdict

Judge throws out Pickett verdict

Publication Date: 04/24/04

LINCOLN — A federal judge Friday overturned a $1.28 billion jury verdict in the Pickett vs. Tyson Fresh Meat case that found the company manipulated cattle prices, said Steve Cady, executive director of the Organization for Competitive Markets.

Cady said Judge Lyle E. Strom overturned the verdict based on technicalities and not the finding that captive supplies harm prices.

David A Domina, an Omaha attorney representing the 30,000 cattlemen plaintiffs, said Friday that Strom’s ruling will be appealed.

Domina said Strom found that the plaintiffs’ proof of damages was not sufficient and the cattlemen did not disprove all Tyson’s claimed justifications for use of captive supplies or long-term contracts to acquire cattle for slaughter. He said cattlemen claim those contracts are used to manipulate market prices.

He said appeal papers will be filed immediately. The case will be reviewed by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit in Atlanta.

“We are deeply disappointed with the court’s ruling today, and will immediately ask the court of appeals to review the matter,” Domina said.

He said the plaintiffs remain confident that they will prevail in the end.

“People in the industry know what has happened to our cattlemen, and why,” Domina said. “The jury could see it, and we are optimistic the appellate court will, too.”

The case went to trial on Jan. 12 and the jury reached its verdict in favor of the plaintiffs on Feb. 17 after a four-week trial. Nebraska cattle producers, Chris Abbott of Gordon and Bob Rothwell of Hyannis, were two of the original six plaintiffs in the case, which was filed in 1996.

Last month, the federal judge presiding over the Alabama-based class-action lawsuit against Tyson denied the plaintiffs’ motion to enter a $1.2 billion judgment against the company.

Cady said Strom on Friday left intact the finding that captive supplies harmed all cash sellers of fed cattle to Tyson in the amount of nearly $1.3 billion. The court also left intact the finding by the jury that the market for fed cattle is national.

But Cady said the court found that there were legitimate business reasons for captive supply, including that Tyson was guaranteed a consistent, reliable supply of cattle and that Tyson needed captive supplies to meet the competition where other packers engaged in the practice.

Tyson Fresh Meats is a subsidiary of Tyson Foods Inc., an Arkansas-based company that is the world’s largest processor and marketer of chicken and red meat products. The company operates a number of beef processing plants in Nebraska, including Dakota City and Lexington.

In responding to Friday’s announcement, Tyson Chairman, John Tyson, said the decision was a victory for both the company and cattlemen across the country.

“It protects the freedom of producers to market cattle the way they want, and it affirms our strongly held belief that our livestock practices are proper,” Tyson said.

Fred Stokes, OCM president, said the ruling on technicalities does an “extreme disservice to going forward with more open and competitive markets in the cattle industry that is unencumbered by abuses in market power.”

He said the court did not dispute the fact that the practice harms cattle producers.

“It also did not dispute the fact that cattle quality was lower with captive supply cattle and higher with spot market cattle,” Stokes said. “We think that the jury verdict is entitled to far more respect by the judiciary.”

The court’s finding on legitimate business expectations turned on a dispute of law, Stokes said. He said the plaintiffs argued that where the harm of captive supply outweighs any claimed benefits, the court should find the practice unlawful.

Also, the court accepted the defendant’s argument that even if the harm was severe, if there is any benefit at all, the law was not broken.

“It is not logical that where, for example, there is $100 of harm by Tyson, proof of a $1 benefit makes the net of $99 harm to producers go away,” he said. “Tyson was not able to quantify any benefit received by captive supply in dollar terms. They merely made assertions. Further, it is outlandish that Tyson should be allowed to use strategic price manipulation strategies just because other dominant packers are doing it.”

Stokes said the court additionally held that there was no proof that persons who sold cattle in 1999 and 2000 were harmed.

“We are unsure how the court could find no proof of harm in 1999 and 2000 where captive supplies were going up rapidly when the court accepted that captive supplies lowered prices in all other portions of the eight-year class period,” he said. “It just does not make any sense and does a disservice to cattle producers wanting a fair price.”
© The Grand Island Independent

Posted in Cattlemen's Legal Fund | 1 Comment

Cattlemen: Nebraska is key in battles with meatpackers

Cattlemen: Nebraska is key in battles with meatpackers
  George Lauby (North Platte Bulletin)
 
 

Click for larger view

April 2 — Nebraska is a key state in a fierce struggle for control of the American live cattle industry, and there are no gray lines, five men involved in the Pickett v. IBP antitrust case said in North Platte Friday.

“What we do will determine if we have a future in the cattle industry,” rancher and cattle feeder Bob Rothwell of Hyannis told cattle producers, businessmen and reporters at a press conference hosted by the North Platte Bulletin.

Rothwell and four other men made statments and fielded questions for nearly two-and-a-half hours.

Rothwell is one of six cattlemen who were plaintiffs in the Pickett v. IBP lawsuit in January and February in U.S. District Court in Montgomery, Ala. Before reaching trial, the lawsuit was in litigation for eight years. The trial ended after a month of testimony and five days of jury deliberations.

The jury found IBP manipulated prices through the use of forward price contracts, which are agreements to buy cattle with “the price-to-be-set-later,” said Steve Cady, executive director of the Lincoln-based Organization for Competitive Markets.

Cady said the Pickett v. Tyson verdict would only change those kind of cattle sales arrangments, not others such as the Nebraska Corn Fed Beef program.

Several Nebraska cattlemen testified during the Pickett v. Tyson trial, and all of them testified for the plaintiffs, Cherry County rancher Chris Abbott said.

Although Rothwell and others thought for several years that captive supplies of cattle were lowering cattle prices, they were more convinced than ever after seeing evidence in the courtroom.

“They had the best opportunity to hear the best arguments, they had the best attorneys under the best of conditions, and the jury determined they had been wrecking financial damage to the beef markets,” agreed Bill Bullard of the Ranchers-Cattlemen Action Legal Fund, a Montana-based ranchers advocacy group.

Rothwell said it will probably require a court-ordered injunction to force meatpackers to stop using forward price contracts.

That could take several months, even a year or two, Cady said.

The cattlemen said they resorted to legal action because their traditional political action group, the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association, is deferring to meatpackers’ interests instead of asserting cattlemen’s interests when it comes to lawmaking, Rothwell said.

Also, the United States Department of Agriculture is not enforcing the 1921 Packers and Stockyards Act, the law by which Tyson was tried, Bullard said.

The men said the Pickett v. IBP verdict gives them a firm base to continue their legal action, and the anti-trust issue is gaining interest in Congress. Also, other court cases are underway against Swift and Excel, two of the nation’s four meatpackers that buy 80 percent of the cattle in the United States.

The plaintiffs said they would continue pressing their case until meatpacking companies stop using forward price contracts. Ultimately, who will own farms and ranches in the years to come is at issue.

Abbott said they have a place to stand now.

“It took us eight years to get in the ball game,” he said. “With this verdict we are on first base.”

 

 
The North Platte Bulletin – Published 4/3/2004
Copyright © northplattebulletin.com – All rights reserved.
Flatrock Publishing, Inc. – 203 S Chestnut St – North Platte, NE 69101
Posted in Cattlemen's Legal Fund | Leave a comment

Falfurrias . . . a question of power

Subject: Mr. Swift and Mr. Hoover – It is not a question of what is right…it is a question of power…

“Mr. Swift and Mr. Hoover” is the title of Chapter 9 from the book, Falfurrias, by Dale Lasater. 

A link to a PDF copy of the chapter is below.

The book is an excellent history of the cattle industry dating back to the late 1800’s. Chapter 9 memorializes the events leading up to the passage of the P&S Act. Some things never change…

Excerpt:

“The crop of beef and mutton marketed the past six months has been taken from producers at the market centers of the country at much less than the cost of production.  The consumers…have paid higher prices than ever for these staples.”

I’m proud to know the Lasater family. As you will see from reading the book, their contributions to the cattle industry have been significant.

The book is available from:

Dale Lasater

Lasater Grassland Beef

P.O. Box 38

Matheson, Colorado 80830

(719) 541-2855

Click the link below to download file. 

MrSwiftandMrHoover

Posted in Cattlemen's Legal Fund | Leave a comment

America’s Cattlemen’s Trial

It was Monday, February 9, 2004 – the evening before closing argument.  The jury would get the case tomorrow.  I was in my hotel room worrying about the result.  We had put on a strong case with four weeks of evidence showing that Tyson had used captive supplies to push cattle prices lower.  But would the jury see it that way?  Would they find that we missed something?

We had claimed the right side of this Alabama courtroom throughout the trial.  It was nearest the jury.  Tyson’s attorneys had claimed the left side.  They could see the jury more directly.

The jury.  Seven women and five men.  Three were African-American, nine were white.  They were soon to hold the future of the cattle industry in their hands.  When they were selected, many of them were not pleased with the prospect of having several weeks taken away from their jobs, their families, and their leisure time.  But they had intently listened to the witnesses and the video taped depositions.  They had closely examined the exhibits displayed on three computer monitors in front of the jury box.  They were taking their job seriously.

I walked down the hall of the hotel to the makeshift office where David Domina, plaintiff’s counsel from Omaha, was preparing the closing argument.  David, his wife Carol, and Kim Weber from his staff had transformed one room in this hotel outside Montgomery, Alabama into the War Room.  The attorneys, the plaintiffs, their families and supportive cattlemen had taken over much of the hotel.  It was like living in a compound.  We lived to the same rhythm.  We got up, we ate together in the dining hall, we went to court, we came back, we reviewed the day, we ate, we slept.  Day after day.

What would the jury do?  How long would they deliberate?  Tyson’s attorneys had tried to convince them that there were legitimate reasons for captive supplies.  Those reasons sounded logical in theory, but their evidence was surprisingly weak.  After eight years of preparation, hiring expensive economists, and funding many studies, was this all they had?  Did the jury see it the same way I did?

David Domina had just completed a re-draft of his closing argument before I walked into the room.  Each side had 90 minutes to argue tomorrow morning.  David would present for 70 minutes, then attorney Tom Green would speak for Tyson, then attorney Joe Whatley from Birmingham would rebut for the cattlemen for 20 minutes.  Chris Abbot, Bob Rothwell, Mike Callicrate, and Pat Goggins, four of the plaintiffs named in the case, were in the room and liked what they saw.  They made some suggestions.  They left.  I made some suggestions.

Johnny Smith from South Dakota could not make the closing arguments.  He had a livestock auction market to run.  Henry Lee Pickett from Alabama was home.  He would come in the morning.

Tuesday morning came.  We got up, we ate, we went to court.  The right side of the court room filled with cattlemen and their families.  The federal marshals supervised everybody passing through the metal detectors at the courthouse entrance.  They called it “the cowboy hat trial.”  The left side of the courtroom included Tyson’s lawyers and some cowboy overflow from the right side.  This was the day.

Judge Lyle E. Strom opened court.  He looked to David Domina and said “proceed.”  David stood in front of the jury speaking in quiet tones that the rest of us strained to hear.  He said “This is America’s Cattlemen’s Trial.  You can choose whether the cattle industry looks like this…”  – he motioned to the right of the courtroom filled with cowboys and their families – “or whether it looks like this…” – he motioned to the left where Tyson’s attorneys sat with a barely perceptible flinch.

He explained how Tyson used captive supplies to accumulate inventory.  He recounted how Bruce Bass, Tyson’s head cattle buyer, admitted that he set the price lower when his cattle inventory was high.  He said that the Packers & Stockyards Act was like a fence.  The packers were to stay on their side, the cattlemen were to stay on the other side.  Good fences make good neighbors.  But the packers had jumped the fence, controlling not only cattle demand, but cattle supply.  Supply and demand had broken down.  “The fence needs mending.”  He asked the jury to fix it.

Tyson’s Tom Green got up to speak.  Green was listed as one of America’s top ten litigators by the National Law Journal.  His strategy was first to attack the six plaintiff class representatives.  He demeaned one after the other – Chris Abbot, Bob Rothwell, Mike Callicrate, Pat Goggins, Henry Lee Pickett, Johnny Smith.  They were radicals – out of the mainstream.  Lee Pickett’s young son sat in the room, startled and sad for his father.

Then Green attacked the plaintiff’s experts, Robert Taylor of Auburn and Catherine Durham of Oregon State.  Green further explained why Tyson had many legitimate business reasons for captive supply.  He told the jury they should find for Tyson because of these reasons.  He sat down.

Judge Strom nodded to the plaintiffs to again proceed.  Joe Whatley got up.  He told the jury why Tyson’s reasons were not legitimate.  Those reasons are not legitimate if they are contrived, he said.  They are not legitimate if they are pretext… or not proven… or not quantified.  He then explained how the jury could calculate the amount of money that Tyson had taken from America’s cattlemen, their families, and their communities.  Joe asked them to find for the plaintiffs so that Tyson would give that money back.

The judge read his instructions to the jury.  The instructions favored, in our view, Tyson.  We had argued strenuously against some of those instructions the day before when the jury was out.  But we had to live with them.  If the jury ruled for us, Tyson would have fewer arguments against the verdict because the instructions favored them.  Judge Strom had given the case to the jury.  Court adjourned.

12 ordinary people.  After all my meetings in the countryside, presentations before Congressional committees, Senate votes, House hearings, USDA criticisms, it all came down to 12 people whom I had never met.  Whom Tyson’s attorneys, lobbyists, public relations personnel, and executives had never met.  Never had the playing field been so level.

We went to lunch – the attorneys, the plaintiff class representatives, their families, the cattlemen observers, and me.  I wasn’t hungry.  We talked together about the weather, about the markets, about our families left at home.  We speculated about what the jury was thinking – despite the futility of that discussion.

By Wednesday morning many of the cattlemen went home.  The day came and went.  Thursday came.  The jury had a question, submitted in writing to Judge Strom.  There was a brief bustle as the attorneys from both sides read the question, debated the answer, and Judge Strom wrote the answer to be taken by the marshal back to the jury room.  Some of us played cards.  Lee Pickett’s son was so upset by Green’s remarks about his dad, that he felt too ill to go to school for three days.

On Friday, more of us went home, including me.  David stayed with his wife Carol and Kim Weber.  There was another jury question.  The question seemed to show the jury was favoring us.  Tyson’s attorneys appeared worried.  I called to get the story.  We were hopeful even as we were afraid to hope.

Monday, court holiday.

Tuesday morning, February 17, 2004.  We thought this could be the day, but how could we know?  The case had started in the last century – 1996.  Is this the day?  The phone rang in my office at 12:10 pm Eastern Standard Time.  It was David Domina.  The jury had come back.  All 12 jurors had unanimously agreed with us on all questions.  They found that Tyson damaged the cash market by an amount exceeding $1.28 billion.  Henry Lee Pickett was crying.  To him, the verdict was not only for cattlemen, but for his son.

I said “Thank you David.”  I hung up the phone.  We won.

By Michael Stumo, Attorney for the Cattlemen

Posted in Cattlemen's Legal Fund | Leave a comment

IN-DE-FENCE-A-BULL

IN-DE-FENCE-A-BULL

Lee Pitts 2/24/03

Front Page Story Livestock Market Digest
For the last few years I’ve had these nagging feelings of OPTIMISM regarding the possibility that cattlemen would NOT become a herd of contract cowboys working as serfs on their own land for the benefit of the big three packers. Admittedly, there was a brief bout of depression following the merger of our checkoff dollars with the NCBA, but then it dawned on me: That merger and the increasing arrogance of NCBA afterwards was what made cowboys mad enough to change the direction our industry was headed. Without it we may never have had R-CALF or Pickett versus IBP.
I’ve said for the past several years that three things needed to happen to keep us from becoming nothing more than chicken farmers in cowboy boots. First of all we needed to develop an organization that truly represented the wishes of the cow-calf operators in this country. Thanks to Leo McDonnell and the meteoric rise of R-CALF that is now a reality. Secondly, the NCBA needed to be separated from the checkoff. Taking away their money would make it harder for them to pander to the packers and carry their water in Washington DC. This will happen any day now when the Supreme Court refuses to hear their appeal and the checkoff is declared unconstitutional once and for all. (The dairy checkoff was the latest to be declared unconstitutional.)
I have thought for some time now that the our best chances of remaining free and independent cattlemen rested with the brave cowboys who took on IBP in the now famous captive supply case: Pickett versus IBP/Tyson. Like my good friend and Picket plaintiff Johnny Smith always said, “We knew we could win if we got the facts before a jury of our peers.” Eight years later the cowboys finally got their chance in front of a jury and just like Johnny Smith prophesied those twelve Alabama jurists proclaimed IBP/Tyson guilty of using captive supplies to manipulate cattle prices.
Fred Stokes of The Organization for Competitive Markets called the verdict “the greatest day for cattlemen since the passage of the Packers & Stockyards Act.”
The P & S Act of 1921 eventually broke the stranglehold held by the big five packers of that era. Eighty-three years later the Pickett decision has the potential to do the same thing to today’s big three.
Winners and Losers
Among the winners in this case are the plaintiffs: Henry Lee Pickett, Mike Callicrate, Chris Abbot, Robert Rothwell, Johnny Smith, Pat Goggins and anyone else who owns a cow in this country. A potentially huge winner is their lead attorney, David Domina, who took the case on a contingency meaning he got nothing unless the ranchers won. Legally the Pickett plaintiffs are said to represent a class of approximately 30,000 cattlemen who sold to IBP exclusively on the cash market from 1994 to 2002, but in reality they represented everyone striving for a free and independent cattle industry. The $1.28 BILLION dollar judgment against Tyson won’t break the company, but if the courts force them to give up their sweetheart deals and captive supplies they’ll have to find another way to pilfer the pockets of ranchers.
The losers were IBP/Tyson, the USDA, NCBA and slick papered journalists who have been promoting “strategic alliances” and captive supply. Make no mistake, during this trial their traitorous stands were exposed and their actions proven indefensible.
The trial, which lasted about a month with the jury deliberating for four days, revolved around the plaintiff’s claim that IBP used contracts with a select few beef producers like Cactus, Simplot, CattleCo, Beef Marketing Group, Pioneer Feeders and others to create a captive supply of cattle which they could use to manipulate prices. The plaintiffs argued Tyson relied on this captive supply when cattle prices were high and entered the cash market for cattle only when prices were low. They also argued that such a scheme violated the 1921 Packers and Stockyards Act which is supposed to prohibit packers from employing any “unfair, unjustly discriminatory, or deceptive practice or device” or from making preferential sweetheart deals.
One of the stars of the trial was Auburn ag economist Robert Taylor. He calculated for every 100,000 head of captive supply cattle killed by Tyson the packer reduced the price they’d have to pay in a fair market by $5.62 per hundredweight. When you consider that half of the 9.5 million head of cattle Tyson slaughters each year are captive, Taylor calculated that between early 1994 and late 2002 (the period covered by the lawsuit) IBP/Tyson cheapened their cattle back by 2.1 BILLION dollars!
By many accounts the Tyson team put on a weak defense. This is easily explained: they had no plausible defense for how they have been ripping you off. Even their own people, put on the stand to defend their actions, ended up helping the cattlemen’s cause. Bruce Bass, head cattle buyer for IBP testified that he informed their 75 cattle buyers four times daily as to the supply of captive supply. He then told his buyers the number of cattle to buy on the spot market and what they should give. Bass also testified that during some weeks IBP owned as much as 190% of its kill needs, nearly double what they’d need for their slaughter plants the following week. When that happened Bass told his buyers to lower their bids for cash cattle.
“The preferential captive supply deals started a market destroying cycle,” said Steve Cady, Director of The Organization for Competitive Markets. “Tyson could pull out of the cash market and destabilize it. Then it would offer more “marketing alternatives” as the remedy for the problem it was creating in the cash market. As it enticed more producers to use captive deals the disease kept getting worse. The disease is a dysfunctional cash market caused by the captive supply treatment.”
Tyson, other packers and most livestock journalists these days argue that captive supply deals and strategic alliances are necessary in order for a packer to acquire the higher quality cattle they need for their branded beef programs. Packer’s professors like Ted Schroeder of Kansas State paraded to the stand and testified that beef quality would go down without captive supply. Clem Ward, an agriculture economist at Oklahoma State University, said after the verdict, “I’m worried that this case will dismantle the alliances that are creating better products for consumers.”
This argument was shot full of holes big enough to drive a semi through. Tyson’s own data revealed that the cattle IBP bought in the open market graded 10% HIGHER than their captive cattle. “For years, packers, the NCBA and land grant economists on the packer payroll claimed that these so-called alliances were necessary to buy high quality cattle to combat declining consumer demand. But the evidence in the Pickett case revealed that captive cattle were of a much lower average quality,” said Stokes.
“It is especially ironic that CattleCo, a large cattle feeding corporation closely tied to Sparks Companies in Memphis, has a very favorable contract with Tyson that allows them to deliver very low quality cattle, 30% average choice grade, without being discounted,” said Steve Cady of OCM. “The average grade in Nebraska is 60 to 65% choice.  Yet, Sparks Companies performed a January 2002 study on the packer ban claiming that captive supplies are necessary to increase beef quality. It is clear that they were not only false, but serving their own profit interests.”
You may recall the Sparks name. The NCBA often cites studies done by that firm to justify the NCBA’s packer friendly positions.
The Real Cattlemen’s Friend
Speaking of the NCBA… How do they justify having Bruce Bass play such a pivotal role in their association, holding such sway over their marketing committee meetings, when he works for a company that has now been found by a jury to have been manipulating the cattle prices paid to the people NCBA supposedly represents?
And why did six brave men have to do this on their own, without any help whatsoever from the supposed national organization for cattlemen? Plaintiff Johnny Smith said, “We beat Goliath without help from what is supposed to be the cattlemen’s best friend, the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association.”
Says OCM executive director Steve Cady, “The NCBA, and the USDA, for that matter, never once helped the Pickett plaintiffs over the eight years this case has been around. That’s pretty astounding. I mean this was the biggest trial in the cattle industry in nearly a century and neither played any role in it? Wow.”
R-CALF stepped up to the plate once again on behalf of grass roots ranchers. R-CALF Directors Leo McDonnell, Kathleen Kelley and Herman Schumacher all testified on behalf of the plaintiffs as did R-CALF member, and Pickett plaintiff, Sam Britt. The rancher from Pasamonte, New Mexico testified that, “The packing industry has been holding us hostage for a long time. They [Tyson/IBP] took over the chickens and hogs, but they just found out cowboys weren’t going to role over and play dead for ‘em!”
Even after the verdict the NCBA was still pushing strategic alliances and captive supplies. Their lobbyist in Washington, Chandler Keys, told BEEF Magazine, “I also think that this decision serves as a wake-up call to the beef industry. If you’re out there involved or trying to get involved in a value-based marketing system, the plaintiffs in this case are trying to take that opportunity away from you. They want to get the industry back to a commodity product.”
Award winning columnist Alan Guebert had a far different take on recent events: “The Alabama jury only did what its buddies at the U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, the market’s legal protector, and friends at the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association (NCBA), the industry’s self-proclaimed protector, failed to do for years. It took an impartial look at the cattle market and declared it a manipulated, stinking mess.”
They Did Nothing While Doing Nothing
Guebert and Cady mentioned another group whose lack of action is totally indefensible: the USDA. One wonders, why did it take a lawsuit eight long years in the making to begin to enforce rules that have been on the books since 1921? Do you know how much more money has been stolen in the meantime? While Omaha, Ogagllala and Oklahoma City burned the USDA fiddled.
Dennis Olson, of the Institute for Ag and Trade Policy said, “This groundbreaking legal action was only necessary because federal law agencies have turned their back on U.S. farmers. It is both disgraceful and inexcusable that secretaries of agriculture under both the Clinton and Bush administrations for years stood idly by and abandoned independent cattle producers to the predatory practices of the meatpacking cartel. This Alabama jury has provided a ray of light for cattlemen and producers alike to follow out of the darkness of the predatory, anticompetitive jungle, and towards the light of fair, open and transparent markets. It is time for federal agencies to step in on behalf of farmers and restore fairness to the marketplace.”
While cattle producers were losing 20% of their share of the consumer beef dollar (from 65% to 45%) the Packers and Stockyard division of the USDA failed to enforce rules already on the books. Our elected representatives have refused to implement a rule proposed by the Western Organization of Resource Councils that would require meatpackers to bid in open, competitive manner for captive cattle supplies. The USDA and NCBA have opposed any new legislation to ban packers from owning livestock by saying we already have enough laws. And that we do. What we don’t have are government agencies or a USDA Secretary with the backbone to enforce them.
The Check Is Not In The Mail
This war isn’t won yet. Tyson intends to ask Judge Lyle Strom to throw out the jury’s verdict and some people think he might because the Judge suggested during trial proceedings that the case appeared weak to him. He could throw out the verdict if he thought the expert witness testimony was defective or the jury failed to follow his instructions. He had already removed any punitive damages from the decision. Judge Strom is also the judge for two more captive supply lawsuits against Excel and Swift. Both are similar to Pickett and the Judge may wait for outcomes in those cases before deciding whether to accept or throw out the Pickett verdict.
Roger McEowen, an ag law expert from Kansas State thinks the verdict is likely to stand. “For there to be some basis for appeal, there would have to be an error in trial court, and I just don’t see any. I think this verdict will stand and I think that is a good thing.”
If Judge Strom accepts the jury verdict, the case moves into a separate trial to determine how the current system of acquiring fat cattle will be fixed. Attorney David Domina told the Wall Street Journal that he plans to ask the court to require that Tyson turn to the open market to buy 90% of the cattle it slaughters. Any decision in this case is also apt to apply to all major beef packers.
If you are part of the class that fed cattle and sold to IBP and wonder where your check is… relax. It will be a while. The decision will be appealed and it will be years before the legal wrangling is over. But money was never the main objective of the plaintiffs anyway. They wanted to change the way packers do business, reestablish open and competitive markets and take back our business. Chances are if your kids, and their kids, are able to become independent cattlemen it will be because these brave men took a stand for justice and freedom. And for that we tip our hats to them.

Posted in Cattlemen's Legal Fund | Leave a comment