I am Joe Maxwell

Joe Maxwell is The HSUS’s Director for Rural Development and Outreach. Michelle Riley/The HSUS

I am Joe Maxwell, a fourth generation family farmer from Missouri, and Director of Rural Development and Outreach for the Humane Society of the United States. HSUS is not asking that you join them, only that we join together to stop NCBA from using check off dollars against our common interest.

I have spent most of my life fighting for family farmers and ranchers, meeting Mike Callicrate along the way.  In the late nineties as a Missouri State Legislator, I sponsored and passed legislation that implemented a state COOL law, a packer ban on ownership of livestock, and, we gave the Missouri Attorney General the authority to implement the Federal GIPSA rules.  US Senator Wellstone was in attendance along with several thousands of farmers and ranchers as Governor Mel Carnahan signed it into law. Ironically, within just a few short years, both men would die in airplane crashes.  Almost immediately after the bill was signed into law in Missouri, I was sued by the Missouri Cattleman’s with support of the NCBA.  Go figure.  We won at the Supreme Court, but it took so long that the bills’ authorization ran out before it could be implemented. Many of you on this email chain remember that.

During this period, Mike Callicrate was on a panel at the Callaway Livestock Center in Missouri trying to convince a packed audience that they should fight the big packers and consolidation. That is when I stood up from a balcony and demanded that the head of the Missouri Cattlemen, who was also on the panel, tell everyone in the room why he had sued me and why they were supporting the big packers.  That is how Mike and I met.  That was in the late nineties.  

Today, I am working with HSUS because they are not our enemy.  They are the enemy of Corporate Ag and its unsustainable practices.  They oppose the abuse to our environment, the farmer/rancher, the worker, and the animals.  I oppose those things too. 

In the 1980’s, we could get tractorcades and hundreds, if not thousands, to rally for the family farmer and rancher.  I remember in the 80’s, Jesse Jackson standing on the steps of the Missouri state capitol in front of an overflowing crowd of farmers chanting “We are Somebody”.  I remember in the 90’s when we were at the Boone County Fairgrounds- Wellstone came to speak and Carnahan signed the farm bill that Gary Wiggins, Sam Leake and myself had passed. We filled the building.  Unfortunately, today, unless Cargill, Monsanto, NCBA, NPPC and the Farm Bureau sanction the event we are lucky to get 50 people to attend.  I stood with Dick Gephardt and a few of you on this email chain against NAFTA and WTO influence over our markets.  You remember don’t you?

“I know of no species with less instinct for survival than the family farmer.” Dr. Harold Breimyer

Last year, with the discussions starting over the farm bill, I realized there were not enough of us left to make the fight.  Not that we wouldn’t go to battle, but we were not going to be able to hold the line on the small victories we had gained in the past; therefore, when Wayne Pacelle stopped me in the halls of the state capitol and asked me what I thought, I told him.  It made me think.  I then began talking to nontraditional supporters to see if they would join our cause.  Having worked with HSUS as a legislator on anti-cock fighting legislation and having had the conversation with Wayne, they were a likely ally, folks who in the past we may have seen as our adversaries, but today we are finding common ground.

HSUS was looking for somebody to help them in the agriculture community who had a background in the family farm and independent rancher cause.  HSUS has committed to finding ways to help the independent rancher and family farmer sustain their operations, they asked me to help.  With my help, they are committed to moving their membership and support base of 11 million people to fight for our cause.  I have told them the proof is in the pudding and they are showing me they are sincere in this effort.  They did support the GIPSA regulation and continue to support COOL.  They had their federal lobbyist team make calls and send emails.  They are working with the Nebraska Farmers Union to help find markets for family farmers and independent cattlemen. They are doing the same thing in Colorado, Ohio, North Carolina, Indiana and Iowa.

Because of past fights and because Corporate Ag continues to steal our names, all of agriculture has been getting a black eye for the extreme agriculture practices that Big Ag deploys in the name of Greed.  Big Ag uses your family and mine to whitewash their filth and it’s causing many of our consumers to think we are all bad actors and that they can’t trust our food, especially meat.  HSUS has agreed to help highlight what is good in agriculture; to show their 11 million members and supporters our face, give us back our name and promote our good stewardship for the animals and the land. 

So, you bet I am working with them.  Not because there is no other hope, but because I believe it is the right thing to do.  I am determined to win. Recently, I was accused of trying to divide agriculture.  I never thought of it that way.  What I am trying to do is keep Corporate Ag from using my face, your face, or any other independent rancher’s or family farmer’s face to protect their bad practices.  If that divides us, so be it.

Every year there are less of us.  Big Ag is driving us off the land and has been for over 30 years. Look at the USDA reports or just drive down the road and see how few of us are left.  You blame that on HSUS?  It is not our enemy.  As you are tired of seeing the NCBA use our check off dollars to lobby against our interests and those of other agriculture sectors, so are they.  That is the common ground that OCM found.  We should focus on the law suit and use whatever resources are available to win.

God has blessed me with friends like Mike Callicrate and many of you on this email chain.  I hope that others of you who are receiving this email will stand with us.  If you can’t stand with us then I ask that you not stand against us. 

Thank you and God Bless.

Posted in Beef Checkoff, HSUS | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Lies, distortions and lawsuits

Farm and Food File for the week beginning Sunday, Aug. 26, 2012

by Alan Guebert

Somewhere along the line it became acceptable to bend and break the record of public figures and firms without any consequence whatsoever. Shortly thereafter distortion and deception replaced discussion and debate and yelling and lying replaced compromise and progress.

And that’s just in agriculture; in politics it’s even worse.

The latest farm and food fight centers on the legal battle that pits the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s management of the beef checkoff against long-time checkoff critic Mike Callicrate, a Kansas rancher who owns the Colorado-based Ranch Food Direct.

But it’s more than just the she-said, he-said checkoff standoff.

That unending fight would end if USDA simply conducted a multi-year audit of NCBA’s checkoff contracts. Past efforts to do just that, however, have been stiff-armed by NCBA’s powerful Capitol Hill allies who claim any audit of NCBA’s books is a waste of government time and money.

This political cover, well-irrigated by NCBA and its meatpacker members, allows the tiny cattle group (less than four percent of all U.S. cattle producers belong) outsized power as a political organization and as a checkoff contractor. That two-hatted trick also carries financial benefits for NCBA.

According to NCBA’s 2009 IRS Form 990 filings, the latest available, just $3.3 million of its $58.7 million in reported revenue came from membership dues. Most of the remainder came either directly or indirectly from the checkoff.

Threats to this rich river of revenue—and Callicrate’s federal lawsuit is an enormous threat—are met with cowboy hellfire and ranch brimstone.

In the past, NCBA has called on its in-the-pocket politicians and checkoff-benefiting media to sing its praises and deflect checkoff queries. This time, however, it was handed a loaded gun by two tough critics, Fred Stokes, outgoing president of the Organization for Competitive Markets, and Callicrate, OCM’s incoming president.

Stokes, a 77-year-old retired Army major, announced the federal lawsuit (that names Callicrate as its only plaintiff) Aug. 10 in a kick-off to OCM’s annual meeting.

In explaining the lawsuit, Stokes noted that OCM had asked attorneys at the Humane Society of the United States to examine rafts of checkoff material OCM had received from USDA through the Freedom of Information Act to assess the merits of any possible suit. HSUS attorneys did so for free.

After that revelation the sky fell on OCM, Stokes and Callicrate. Everyone with a wide-brimmed hat condemned the group and its leaders for taking any assistance from the Humane Society, a group mainline farm organizations reflexively loathe.

NCBA President J.D. Alexander fired first when, according to a NCBA press release later that day, he “expressed disgust… that (OCM) has formed a partnership with the (HSUS) to destroy more than 25 years of market development and consumer demand building by the Beef Checkoff Program.”

Alexander was wrong; OCM had not formed a “partnership” of any kind with HSUS. As Stokes explained, Humane Society attorneys, at OCM’s request, read checkoff documents to offer their unpaid judgment on whether a suit was advisable.

The checkoff lawsuit, in fact, was written and filed, pro bono, by Daniel Owen and G. Gabriel Zorogastua of Polsenelli Shughart PC, a Kansas City, MO law firm known for its antitrust expertise.

Worse, Alexander’s hyperbolic “destroy more than 25 years of market development and consumer demand building” is not just a personal opinion, it’s fact-defying baloney.

Since the 1987 start-up of the beef checkoff the number of U.S. beef operations has fallen from 1.01 million to 742,000, American retail sales of beef per capita have plummeted from 78.7 lbs. to 60.8 lbs., and the U.S. cattle herd has fallen from 102.1 million head to 90.8 million.

There are reasons for this dismal performance, but “market development,” “consumer demand,” and $1.5 billion of checkoff money would not be three of ‘em.

Additionally, as the American cattle sector continues a decades-long trend of losing an estimated 1,000 producers per month, the nation continues to outsource its beef. In the first six months of 2012, U.S. beef imports are up 21 percent and U.S. cattle imports are 22 percent over 2011.

And here’s another hard fact: HSUS, Callicrate and Stokes did nothing to bring about this atrocious record of checkoff failure.

So why is NCBA, a group that 94 percent of all cattlemen voluntarily choose not to join, making them the bogeyman for beef’s woe?

Because we sit silently as distortion and deception replace discussion and debate and yelling and lying replaces compromise and progress. Don’t worry; the lying and the yelling won’t kill democratic institutions.

The silence, however, might.

© 2012 ag comm

The Farm and Food File is published weekly in more than 70 newspapers in North America. Contact Alan Guebert at http://www.farmandfoodfile.com.

Posted in Beef Checkoff, HSUS | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Callicrate says HSUS key in filing lawsuit

Brownfield Ag News for America
August 21, 2012 By Julie Harker

[audio:http://nobullmikecall.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/120820_MikeCallicratebrownfieldagnews.mp3|titles=120820_MikeCallicratebrownfieldagnews]

The new president of the Organization for Competitive Markets (OCM) says he could not have filed his lawsuit against the Beef Checkoff without the help of the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS).

Mike Callicrate, the sole plaintiff in the lawsuit filed in Kansas, that accuses the Beef Checkoff of misappropriating funds, says the HSUS did the groundwork but is NOT a party to the suit.

“I tell you what,” says Callicrate, “OCM vetted the HSUS pretty well. I’m on their Colorado ag council. We are NOT in bed together. We are NOT joining organizations.”

Callicrate tells Brownfield that the HSUS donated labor when the OCM requested and received a truckload of documents from the USDA in a Freedom of Information request about the agency’s dealings with the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association, Cattlemen’s Beef Board and the Beef Operating Board.

“HSUS and their legal staff,” Callicrate tells Brownfield Ag News, “They hired people to go through these documents and carefully analyze the information that was in them. This is what gave us the basis for this lawsuit, to be able to file it.”

Callicrate says he and his organization have one thing in common with the HSUS. “We believe that family farm and ranch agriculture is the way to feed America – and, it’s also the way that the world can feed itself – Not the Cargill, ADM, Tyson model of extraction and exploitation,” he says.

Callicrate is seeking a permanent injunction against the NCBA receiving any more Beef Checkoff dollars in the future, saying the group uses the funds to influence policies that benefit the NCBA and do not represent the cattle producers who pay into the Checkoff.

The NCBA denies the charges and accuses the OCM of wanting to destroy the Beef Checkoff and working with an anti-animal ag group (HSUS) that wants to destroy animal agriculture.

The law firm of record in the case is Polsinelli Shugart of Kansas City.

Posted in Beef Checkoff, HSUS | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

“Your Right, They’re Wrong.” – Will Harris, White Oak Pastures

Will Harris, White Oak Pastures
2011 SBA Small Business Man of the Year
Photo by Casey Dixon
© Copyright 2012 Albany Herald

Will Harris, White Oak Pastures, in support of HSUS help on checkoff lawsuit:
[audio:http://nobullmikecall.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/willharrishsussupport.mp3]

“Hey Mike, this is Will Harris in Georgia, White Oak Pastures, and I don’t expect you to call me back. I called to tell you that I read where the cattle folks castigated ya pretty good for partnering up a little bit with the HSUS, and I wanted you to know that you were right and they’re wrong.

“I think that the HSUS agenda is a whole lot closer to White Oak Pasture’s program than NCBA’s agenda.

“HSUS actually just featured White Oak Pastures in a magazine – something they put out, and I was proud they did it and I recieved some behind my back criticism for that from some of my cattle brethren. And, I know they’ll never say it to my face, but I think you’re right and those guys are wrong. And congratulations. I’m proud to call you a friend.

“My voice is about gone. Got a little laryngitis but I’ll talk to you later.”

Back to the Land, Page 4: Will Harris Lets Nature Lead the Way
Georgia farmer’s animals are pasture-raised without chemicals or drugs
All Animals Magazine July/August 2012

Posted in Beef Checkoff, HSUS | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Callicrate rails against NCBA, explains HSUS involvement

Thursday • August 16th, 2012
AgriTalk Radio

Representing the Organization for Competitive Markets (OCM), beef producer Mike Callicrate appeared on AgriTalk radio Tuesday to discuss the organization’s lawsuit against USDA and the Cattlemen’s Beef Board, which seeks to end NCBA’s role as a beef checkoff contractor.
[audio:http://media.cattlenetwork.com/audio/Callicrate.mp3]

NCBA’s CEO Forest Roberts provided a response.
[audio:http://media.cattlenetwork.com/audio/RobertsOCM.mp3]

Posted in Beef Checkoff, HSUS | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment